Trollpasta Wiki:List of POTM and FOTM Winners

An archived list of the winners of the monthly Pasta of the Month and Fail of the Month polls. Users would be able to nominate specific trollpastas and creepypastas before they were added on a timed-poll that all users could vote on. The winners of the polls would be featured on the site's homepage for a month. This lasted from March 2013 up until the wiki's closure in August 2018.

POTM was for trollpastas, while FOTM was for not-so-good creepypastas (to put it lightly). Pastas with no links to them were deleted either due to poor quality, the author requesting their deletion, or vote manipulation.

2013
Month	POTM	FOTM	Additional info
March	TROLLPASTA QUIZ	Time-Travel Journal
April	TEH DAY OF ALL TEH CEEB	BROKEN	The POTM was deleted later on due to poor quality.
May	Squidwardz Suicide	My Immortal
June	Spidereses	CeepyConroy's Let's Plays OF DEATH	The POTM was deleted later on due to graphic descriptions of sex between characters who are strongly hinted to be underage.
July	404	King of Equestria
August	Tha Tommizzle & Jerrizzle Theory	The Suicide Channel	The POTM was deleted years later per request of the author, who thought it was crap.
September	Same as previous month	Same as previous month
October	Shrek is Love	Jimmy Neutron Happy Family Hour Lost Episode
November	A Dexter's Lab Fanfic	Same as previous month
December	PATRIXXXIA	Shrek Is Not Drek	The POTM was deleted years later due to poor quality. The FOTM was actually a trollpasta, but won anyway.
2014
Month	POTM	FOTM	Additional info
January	EVIL KERMIXXX	Youtube 2
February	Super Mario 64 secret beta cartridge	Sonic.exe
March	Bill O Riley writes a clopfic	Crystal.HTML
April	Cavestory.exeavi	Rabeckah The Killer
May	Does anyone know a good plumber?	Ihsoy
June	Sanic.exe	Aladdin is Dead	Sanic.exe was deleted due to its poor quality and vote manipulation.
July	The Polish Nap Experiment	Super Mario World: The Lost World
August	Sir Patrixxx	Sakurai's Secret
September	NES SPONGEBOXXX CHAPTER 1&2 Earth & Mars	Blood Whistle
October	The story of my chiken that got murdareous after reading a werd spam letter and i had 2 hide	Dofaemon	The POTM story was later deleted due to its poor quality
November	The Haunted Paperclip	Eric Gets Grounded for Infinity Years
December	Pokemanz: Remotely Off-colour Maroon	Jason Michael
2015
Month	POTM	FOTM	Additional info
January	The Giant, Creepy-Ass-Hairless-Spooky monster	How I Met a Terrible Fate	The POTM was later deleted due to its author's bad behavior, but was reuploaded a few years later.
February	A Meeting with AL-Qaida (improved version)	Mario Kart 64: Driven
March	Same as previous month	Same as previous month
April	Sir Sanic	Deadsun Myth	Sir Sanic was deleted the following year due to it being revealed there was vote manipulation.
May	The tale of a slightly insane retard	SBemail 206
June	The most clichéd pasta ever written in the history of Trollpastas, Creepypastas, Spinpastas, Crappypastas, and Shitpastas.exe	Fairly OddParents: Creep Dreams
July	Percy Jackson Goes "Fishing"	Adventure Time: Socrates' Wish (The Lost Episode)
August	The Adventures of Kerbin, Celtic and Bonesy 7 The Dank Leviathan	Dig Dug	The POTM was deleted due to vote manipulation
September	Friday	Clockwork: Your Time Is Up
October	Turns Out I'm Not Allergic to Milk	I Can Fix This
November	Who was Skeleton?	School Killings
December	I Sexually Identify As An Attack Helicopter	You've Had It, Charlie Brown
2016
Month	POTM	FOTM	Additional info
January	Chicken Nuggers	Cupcakes (Original Fanfic)
February	Mrfruit.avi	The Haunting Melody
March	Treats of Insanity	ROSE SLEEPYEYES
April	Prank Ideas XD XD (COLLAB)	Amazing World of Gumball - The Grieving
May	The day my dad kicked me out of the house and I was forced to go outside for more than 5 minutes and it was horrible	Voicebox
June	The Boy Who Loved to Read	Frozen Lost Clip
July	Minecraft Version 6.6.6	Sonic.exe/Round 2
August	Fuck You, Charlie Brown	Spongecry.avi
September	Same as previous month	SpongecryII.avi
October	Same as previous month	K Y O K I
November	The Legend of Finger Guy	LIARS	LIARS was deleted due to worries about possible licensing issues.
December	Monkey Cloning	The Truth Behind Super Mario
2017
Month	POTM	FOTM	Additional info
January	The New Toy - A Lost Toy Story Beta Tape	Jeff the Killer
February	Sonic.exe: Vietnamese Crystal Edition	Hi um i am having trouble posting. so heres my story.
March	Pearl Gets Herself Dead	Mario's Mistake
April	I HAT U	Zelda's Death
May	Morgan Freeman Loses His Voice	Charlie the Killer
June	The Curse of the Overcooked Steak	Rouge exe
July	HitLEr.exe	Such Words
August	How to Summon Herobrine	I Tried to Submit this Pasta to the Creepypasta Wiki but it was Rejected and it Made me sad because it was an ok Pasta
September	Donald Trump Kills the Creepypasta Universe	Lucario's Pain	Lucario's Pain was later deleted due to containing graphic descriptions of underage rape.
October	The Totally Legit iCarly Theory	Time Cube
November	Sexual Offender Man	The Destruction of Bikini Bottom
December	HELLO I HAVE NO EYES	A Christmas Creepypasta
2018
Month	POTM	FOTM	Additional info
January	A Kirby Fanfic (HIGHLY NSFW)	Teletubbies: The Truth
February	MY HAIR IS ON FIRE!	Rayman 4
March	BOB.EXE	Eyeless Jack
April	Mario says the fuck word	Sassy Mama The Hungry Blood Lover
May	Every Creepypasta Ever	I Tried to Submit this Pasta to the Creepypasta Wiki but it was Rejected and it Made me sad because it was an ok Pasta
June	None	Planktonisdead.exe	The FOTM was actually a trollpasta, but won anyway.
July	Mom.txt	Yoshi's Safari: Death Rally
August	A Small Bit of Belt	SCP-2721	The FOTM was deleted after a new rule stating that no official SCP pages should be uploaded to this site was established.