Trollpasta Wiki:List of Fail of the Month Winners

Useful resources
The RulesQ&AEditing 101Genre ListingClichés ListDo's and Don'ts
Stories
Featured PastasFail of the Month WinnersNew Stories
Archive
POTMLogos and BackgroundsCharactersWiki Timeline

Midway through the month, the admins put up a themed poll of four terrible creepypastas that users can vote on. The story that receives the most votes gets featured on the front page as Fail of the Month.

2024

April (Popular-themed): Hope Is Lost
Stories Votes %
Hope Is Lost 45 44.1%
The McDonald's Building 29 28.5%
Max and Ruby 0004 14 13.7%
Amazing World of Gumball - The Grieving 14 13.7%
Total 102 100%
March (Kid show-themed): Mickey Mouse Clubhouse - "Revenge!"
Stories Votes %
Mickey Mouse Clubhouse - "Revenge!" 35 49.3%
Elmo's Hunt 13 18.3%
Blue's Clues - Sorrow 12 17.0%
Yo Gabba Gabba - Dealing With Passings 11 15.4%
Total 71 100%
February (Sonic-themed): Shadow
Stories Votes %
Shadow 20 34.0%
Insane Sonic - Haunted Mega Drive Cartridge 16 27.1%
Sonic Cursed Adventure 12 20.3%
All My Fault 11 18.6%
Total 59 100%
January (Disney-themed): Disney's CARNAGE
Stories Votes %
Disney's CARNAGE 40 56.3%
Phineas and Ferb Lost Episode 11 15.5%
The Black Friday Incident 10 14.1%
A Goofy Movie (Alternative Ending) 10 14.1%
Total 71 100%

2023

November (Creature/being-themed): The Blood Written Words
Stories Votes %
The Blood Written Words 24 40.6%
Human Predator 17 29.0%
Genocidal Ray 14 23.7%
Buttoneyes 4 6.7%
Total 59 100%
September (Creepypasta character-themed): Jeff The Killer vs. The Rake
Stories Votes %
Jeff The Killer vs. The Rake 25 41.7%
Ultimate Nightmare 15 25.0%
Clockwork: Origins 12 20.0%
A Slender Story 8 13.3%
Total 60 100%
August (Computer/technology-themed): Google Satanic
Stories Votes %
Google Satanic 27 39.1%
Corrupted iPhone 5 18 26.1%
1-Cent Computer 18 26.1%
Computer Virus 6 8.7%
Total 69 100%
June (Video game-themed): Dig Dug
Stories Votes %
Dig Dug 20 29.8%
Wii Are Twisted 17 25.4%
Call of Duty: 666 17 25.4%
Broken Xbox 13 19.4%
Total 67 100%
May (Cartoon Network-themed): Regular Show Lost Episode: "Sorry Pop's..."

"I no longer would like to speak about this incedent, but if you truly want to watch the episode, then I pray that you are not scarred for life, like I was"

A rather uneventful story with the main "horror" revolving around a cartoon character dying (not in a gruesome way), cartoon characters crying (not in a disturbing way), and cartoon characters with realistic, bloodshot eyes (not in a hyper-realistic way?) It's light on violence for a lost media creepypasta (but not on stopwatches), which makes it all the more hilarious the protagonist claimed to have been scarred by the episode, which itself isn't even too far off from a normal episode of the show. Maybe there's some irony with that, but perhaps that would be giving the author too much credit.

Stories Votes %
Regular Show Lost Episode: "Sorry Pop's..." 19 35.9%
Dead Fred 14 26.4%
Ed Edd and Eddy: Lose your Ed 12 22.6%
Sombbles 8 15.1%
Total 53 100%
April (Mario Kart-themed): Mario Kart Black

"'Because…..I played it before with a couple a friends,' The Cashier respond, 'BUT IT WAS PRETTY DAMN TERRIBLE THAT IT TOOK MY FRIENDS!' He yelled, while sobbing loudly, which made everybody in the store stopped for a moment and watched us talking."

Yet another horribly written story in the endless sub-genre of "person's paranormal encounter with gruesome piece of children's media." There are many questionable moments in this one, like when the music gets too loud, they put in earplugs instead of turning the volume down. Or even worse, instead of calling for help when Jacob is killed by Mario in real life (yes this actually happens), his sister runs back to the GameStop where the game was bought and asks the cashier questions about it. This is where the cashier reveals the game also killed his friends, and everyone currently in the store are victims of the game as well. Which begs the question why was GameStop selling this game, and why did the cashier give it away to the main characters knowing it would likely kill one of them? It's a truly mind-numbingly awful story up there with some of the worst creepypasta out there, which explains why it easily won the poll.

Stories Votes %
Mario Kart Black 35 47.3%
Mario Kart 64: Driven 18 24.3%
Mario Kart 3DS Creepypasta 14 18.9%
Mario Kart 64: See You Next Time 7 9.4%
Total 74 100%
March (Nickelodeon-themed): Jimmy Neutron-Boy Killer

"Jimmy's mom asks why did he do it, tears all over her face. Jimmy says that Carl was a terrible friend and a loser and that he deserved to die. His parents then tell him that he is grounded forever."

A good example of a creepypasta that is almost entirely reliant on gore and gruesome imagery in a kids cartoon for cheap scares. Though, none of it is scary and lacks any tension or suspense. It also follows the same generic template most stories in this genre follow: protagonist discovers piece of media and is shocked by its violence, followed by said protagonist discarding the media.

Stories Votes %
Jimmy Neutron-Boy Killer 29 35.4%
Rugrats Lost Episode: Chuckie's Mom 24 29.3%
Drake and Josh Lost Episode 17 20.7%
Fairly Odd Parents Lost Episode: Sweet Revenge 12 14.6%
Total 82 100%
February (Adventure Time-themed): Adventure Time: "Catherine! Catherine!"

"I held onto my pillow and I start gasping, wishing I could shoot the TV."

It's another one of those creepypastas about a children's cartoon that becomes inexplicably violent and begins to communicate with the protagonist in some way. At the end it's seemingly implied the episode was a hallucination caused by a tumor, which may have been an effective premise if the story weren't so poorly written.

Stories Votes %
Adventure Time: "Catherine! Catherine!" 18 32.7%
Adventure Time: The Last 13 23.6%
Adventure Time: Socrates' Wish (The Lost Episode) 12 21.8%
Adventure Time - Jake 12 21.8%
Total 55 100%
January (Pasta of the Year): SpongeBob SquarePants: Rage and Depression

Voted the worst of the FotM winners of 2022.

Stories Votes %
SpongeBob SquarePants: Rage and Depression 16 32.0%
A Close Encounter with the Tails Doll 14 28.0%
Homicidal Liu 11 22.0%
Enderman.mov 9 18.0%
Total 50 100%

2022

December (Winter/Christmas-themed): On one bloody christmas eve

"I ran upstairs scared to death grabed the gun it was a snub nose i held 6 shots i fired all 6 in him he enjoyed it almost like he loved it he pounced on me and went to slash with his thorned mangled hand and i ran downstsairs and the wham my leg snapped i seen the clock it read 6:66pm then i accepted death and let him deliver the final blow this"

You know you're reading a laughably bad story when most of the scares revolve around the tired 666 trope. The series of events are nonsensical, which is made worse by the atrocious grammar, creating a story so fundamentally broken that it's almost charming. It's hard to take any of it seriously, which makes it one of the best examples of a so-bad-it's-good creepypasta.

Stories Votes %
On one bloody christmas eve 29 53.7%
ReindeerGames.exe 15 27.7%
Frosty the Snowman 6 11.1%
Seasonal Cruelty 4 7.4%
Total 54 100%
November (Creature/being-themed): Xelex

"He then said, 'Even Zalgo fears me.' And that was it. Zalgo was one of Lovecraft's creatures he wrote about. I could never imagine anything more powerful than Zalgo, from what I have heard about him. I didn't even think Zalgo existed. I couldn't believe my ears when Xelex said that."

Our protagonist mistakenly summons Xelex, an ancient being that's slaughtered millions of people. The police have a shootout with the creature that goes horribly wrong, where he reveals that even Zalgo fears him. The protagonist is seemingly more shocked at this tidbit rather than the ancient creature firing blue energy beams at a police squad. After retreating home, the protagonist sets the wall on fire after Xelex engulfs the house in darkness. Xelex finds this brave or something so he spares the protagonist from his wrath, the only person he's ever spared. Xelex then disappears after threatening to come back in the future. Like many bad creepypastas, it fails at any real sense of terror but excels in unintentional hilarity.

Stories Votes %
Xelex 22 34.9%
The Blinking Moon 17 26.9%
Rusty Fingers 12 19.0%
Dream Demon 12 19.0%
Total 63 100%
October (Killer-themed): Homicidal Liu

"'I knelt down and remove a ring from my bag" Will you marry me? 'He moved, and with tears in her eyes said' If Liu, I want to marry you. 'We left the restaurant, I had not been so happy in my life, but a damn came with a gun and shot him."

Right out of the gate you can tell something is horribly wrong with this story. The prose is borderline unreadable, rapidly switching from first-person to third-person in the same sentence, which is confusing to say the least. This is due to the story being a victim of Google Translate, as it was originally written in Spanish. The massacre of the English language aside, the story itself is terrible. Right after Liu proposes to his girlfriend Susan, she is shot dead by a random criminal. She ends up dying in the hospital, which sends Liu into a murderous rampage, killing everyone in the hospital, including bed-ridden patients. Liu faces no challenges killing anyone he wants, and since the story is from his point of view, it makes him incredibly overpowered and dull. A must-read garbage creepypasta of the slasher variety.

Stories Votes %
Homicidal Liu 33 42.3%
Jane the Killer 26 33.3%
Eyeless Jack 11 14.1%
Laughing Jack 8 10.2%
Total 78 100%
September (Nintendo 64-themed): How I Met a Terrible Fate

"113 Stars. 113 instead of 103. 113 seconds of falling. 1.1, with 3 cheat codes cracked. 113 eggs to to be painted with gorilla blood. Somehow, the number 113 showed up in the games when played on the Ninterror 64. I looked at the phone number. 100-116-3527. 113. I also examined the 1 that almost always appears as the first number of a phone number. Suddenly , I remembered an easter egg put in every Pixar movie: A113. This stood for a CalTech classroom where Tim Burton and John Lassetter attended classes. The first letter of the alphabet is A. 1113=A113. Wow."

The protagonist discovers the Nintendo 64 "Ninterror 64" he bought for $2 plays glitched and gruesome versions of his N64 games. He marathons about a dozen of the games to see all the horrifying new side-effects, such as sudden violence, cryptic language, and lots of explosions for... some reason. As expected with bad creepypasta of this caliber, many instances of the infamous stopwatch cliché appear throughout. And as if the story weren't bad enough, the protagonist discovers the N64 is likely haunted by the antique shop owner's dead son who loved creepypasta. Yeah, there's nothing else to say.

Stories Votes %
How I Met a Terrible Fate 19 33.9%
Mario Kart 64: See You Next Time 17 30.3%
6664 12 21.4%
Donkey Kong: The 202nd Banana 8 14.2%
Total 56 100%
August (Pokemon-themed): Murderpuff

"I saw my friend in a pink Jigglypuff sweater. I gave a little giggle until I broke into laughter. But I stopped right when I saw it. A knife. His pocket knife. He swore only to use as a whittling knife."

A friend's infatuation with Jigglypuff turns him into a murderous weirdo for... some reason. There's not much of a story, but what is there is bizarre. The knife fight the main character has with the friend is especially comical. A short but quintessential fail.

Stories Votes %
Murderpuff 24 38.1%
Pokemon Green Creepypasta 20 31.7%
Pokemon Wounded Silver 13 20.6%
Unwanted Soul 6 9.5%
Total 63 100%
July (Mario-themed): MaRIo

"To this day, I cannot play Super Mario Bros... And the other morning, I woke up to see 'MaRIo' carved into my arm."

Much like every other bad video game creepypasta, it relies heavily on gruesome imagery within the game as a crutch. Predictably, it ends with the protagonist proclaiming he'll never play the series ever again. There's a funny scene where the game cartridge contains a note inside by the dad that says "you're next." That tells you all you need to know about this story.

Stories Votes %
MaRIo 23 43.3%
Hotel Mario: The 13th Hotel 12 22.6%
Super Haunted Galaxy 11 20.7%
Yoshi's Island Gone Wrong 7 13.2%
Total 53 100%
June (Minecraft-themed): Enderman.mov

"I reluctantly clicked it, and the video started. What we saw horrified us. It was us, as characters in Minecraft, along with all of our family."

A story that implies the protagonist's friend is killed by an Enderman. In real life. That and the fact it portrays gorey Minecraft videos as genuinely terrifying makes it no surprise it won the poll. It's a doozy.

Stories Votes %
Enderman.mov 21 39.6%
Minecraft Mod 11 20.7%
Minecraft Skelie 11 20.7%
Minecraft: The Life of a Block 10 18.8%
Total 53 100%
May (Sonic-themed): A Close Encounter with the Tails Doll

"The Tails Doll was furiously slashing at the door, a piece of the door flew out of the window and the Doll's dark eyes were glaring at me."

Unlike most video game pastas, this one involves a character from the game wreaking havoc in the real world. The story becomes more absurd as it progresses, including a scene where the Tails Doll wields a chainsaw against the protagonist. The outlandish material and horrid writing makes it a laughable fail in every way.

Stories Votes %
A Close Encounter with the Tails Doll 28 36.8%
Sonic's Pentagram 18 23.6%
Sonic Boom: The Fog 18 23.6%
Dr Robotnik's Mean Bean Machine 12 15.7%
Total 76 100%
April (SpongeBob-themed): SpongeBob SquarePants: Rage and Depression

"I couldn't call Stephen Hillenburg because he died, so I decided to call Paul Tibbit. He told me that some SpongeBob hater nearby Nickelodeon Studios must've hijacked the place and created it."

A ridiculous and melodramatic story about SpongeBob going into a deep depression after Patrick dies in a plane crash. The poor writing, odd moments, and terrible dialogue are sure to get a laugh out of anyone.

Stories Votes %
SpongeBob SquarePants: Rage and Depression 24 33.3%
Spongebob Squarepants: The Lost Episode of Season 6 17 23.6%
How Spongebob Started 16 22.2%
Patrick's Leg 15 20.8%
Total 72 100%
March (Worst Creepypasta): Sonic.exe

"Sonic is the very embodiment of evil, he tortures people who play his game in more ways than one and then when he gets bored he drags you into the game, literally drags you to Hell, where he can play with you always, as his toy...."

Perhaps the most infamous video game creepypasta, it's no surprise Sonic.exe won the poll in a landslide. It's a tedious and poorly written slog that relies on clichés and pointless violence for horror. The author's meltdown in response to the story's deletion from Creepypasta Wiki has also gained infamy. In recent years the character of Sonic.exe has managed to stay popular and overshadow the story itself.

Stories Votes %
Sonic.exe 50 35.9%
Happy Appy 28 20.1%
Blood Whistle 27 19.4%
Jeff the Killer 26 18.7%
Red Mist 8 5.7%
Total 139 100%