Category:Not Sure if Troll or Trying to Be Serious
Creepypastas so horrible, that you can't even tell if they're creepypastas or not.
Pages in category "Not Sure if Troll or Trying to Be Serious"
The following 500 pages are in this category, out of 606 total.
(previous page) (next page)0
5
9
A
- A Cursed Nostalgia
- A Demon With A Lisp
- A Kitten's Story: The Adventures of Chatran
- A Love Letter to Creepypasta
- A New Generation: Director's Cut
- A Night of Nick GaS
- A Really Hidden Powerpuff Tape
- A Visit from Jeff
- A weird phone call......(scary but not that scary)
- Abandoned by SEGA
- Acid Does Plague
- Adventure Time: Lost Episode
- Adventures of the Little Koala Lost Episode
- Aggretsuko: Retsuko Says Goodbye
- Alexa's Grieving
- Alexa.bat
- All Gone (awful original version)
- Alligators in the House
- AlphNation - Bye-Bye, Dark
- Always Watch What Part of Latin America You're Going To
- Always Watching
- Amazing World of Gumball: The Pizza: Alternate Ending
- Amiibos Have Feelings....
- Among us (lost early version)
- Angry birds: dust and ash
- Animaniacs Hulu 2020 Reboot: The Fire
- Animaul Crossings: New Blood
- Annie Christmas
- Another Plants vs. Zombies Creepypasta
- Any massacre at midnight
- Apartment 366
- Apartment 3H
- Arcade Nightmare
- Arnold the Octopus
- Around The World In 80 Days Lost episode
- Ashberry
B
- Back to The Future Never Happened Theory
- Bad Bowser
- Bad Choices
- Ball Guy: The Rolling Quest (FINAL BUILD/2024 BUILD)
- Banjo Tooie: The Darkness Rises
- Bart And The Murder Mutants
- Battle For Death Island: Revenge
- Beavis and Butthead - "Fire, Fire, Fire!"
- Beavis and Butthead in: Solitude
- Beetlejuice, Beetlejuice, Beetlejuice
- Better Luck Next Time
- BFB 911: Unknown Kills
- BFDI: TPOT 1 (EARLY DRAFT)
- Billy and Bobby Rare 1988 NES Game
- Blaze.exe
- Blimps in Baltimore
- Blood On My Walls
- Blue's Clues: Help Blue
- Blue's Clues: Where's Blue?
- Blues Clues: Disability Aid for Impaired Humans
- Bluey - Daddy Massacre (FANONPASTA)
- Bluey...?
- Bob can't do it
- Bob's Burgers: Crazy Tina
- Brian Jacques' Redwall Theory
- Broken Roof
- Buhdeuce Abuse
- BuzzFeed A.I
- Bynary Message
C
- C0rRUPT
- Caillou: Darkness
- Caillou: Mommy's Secret
- Camp Lazlo Season Six
- CandleCove In Nick?
- Cannibal Jenny (Lost Episode)
- Captain Flamingo - Origins
- CatDog Banned Episode: The End
- Cell Phone
- Cheap Condoms
- Cheek to Cheek With Death
- Chikn Nuggit: The Ten Secret TikToks
- Classic Cartoons and Baby Shows Theory
- Cleveland Bites the Dust
- Could Jesus be the Antichrist
- Counter-Strike: Source
- Cracked Minecraft
- Cranberry Juice
- Crashbox - Lost Episode
- Crazy Cat
- CREEPIEST CLEVERBOT CHAT EVER
- Crossy Road Unreleased Character
- Crystal Pepsi Lost Commercial
- Curious George - Bill's Bad News
- Cursed Shake Creepypasta
- Cursed YTMND Page
- Cyberplace: Cyberchase's Lost Pilot
- Cyrus Syndrome
D
- Damned Grand Theft Auto 4
- Daniel Tiger's Neighborhood: Cakes (Alternate Episode)
- Daniel Tiger's Neighborhood: Daniel's Last Rites
- Dead Mann
- Dead Mat
- DEADCRY.gif
- Deadpool Slaughterific
- Death By Sega
- Death drugs
- Demo Reel 2: The Backlash
- Demo Reel Lost Episode
- Diddykongracing.jpg
- Dig 1990 - The Actual Movie
- Disney Cinderella is Evil
- Do the Bart...Man...
- Donkey Kong Country: Beta Cartridge
- Donkey Kong Country: DK's Rampage
- Dont leave
- Dont watch it
- Doofenhmirtz's kills everyone
- Dorky's Revenge
- Dot Warner Doll
- Dratini's Cry
- Drowned Sapphire
- DukeyAndFriendsDukeysLastGive.mp4
E
F
- Family Burden
- Family Guy Theory
- Family Guy: Peter's Relationship
- Family Guy: Season 8 Episode 0: The Bloody Sunset
- Fatman
- Fay The Killer
- Felix the Cat
- Finding Nemo Video Game: The Secret Backrooms Level
- FNAT
- Focus Punch 560
- For Glory
- For the birds
- Four Doors
- Freddy Freaker
- Freesmart.avi
- Frozen Lost Clip
- Frozen Minecraft
G
- Game Over...
- Game.exe
- Garfield And Friends: Garfield's Hunt
- Garfield.wmv
- Garry's Mod 666
- Gengars Curse
- GoAnimate
- Golden Girls Lost Episode
- Good and bad tails doll
- Goodbye Pikachu
- Goodbye SpongeBoy
- Goodbye, Sonic
- Google Surprise
- Grand Theft Auto: Satandreas
- Grandma Melinda
- Gravity Falls Lost Episode - My very first pasta
- Gravity Falls: The Lost Episode
- Greatest Freakout Ever Lost Episode
H
- Hacker Team
- Halo Reach Crazy Scary Story
- Happy Family
- Happy Tree Friends: The Lost Special
- Harvey Beaks Lost Episode: The Real World
- Have a Scaly Halloween
- He Caused His Own Fate
- Hell Stick
- Hello?
- Herobrine Is Real
- Herobrine Killed Everything
- Hey Duggee - The Grandparents Badge (Alternate Version)
- Hey Duggee: The Pain Badge
- Him
- Homer's Last Laugh
- Homestuck - Rough Draft
- Homicidal Taco
- Hotel Transylvania 3: Summer Vacation Alternate Ending
- Hotel Transylvania The Series: The Bad Prank
- House No. 13
- How My Friend Became a Zombie
- HowToBasic: Lost Video
I
- I dont understand my condition
- I know what is coming for you
- I'll Never Close My Eyes Again
- Ibi.exe
- Ibi.exe (2024 remake)
- Ibi.exe II: Wanna Play With Me?
- Ibi.exe II: Wanna Play With Me? (2024 remake)
- IIM NOT MAD
- Imaginary Friend
- Impractical Jokers Lost Episode
- Inanimate Insanity S0 E0:Box's True Form
- Insane
- Insane serenity
- Invader Zim: Gir's Rage
J
K
L
- Lavender The Hedgehog .exe
- Lazari
- LazyTown - A Coffin For Stingy
- LazyTown Episode 4355
- LazyTown: The Anime Series
- Leap Frog: The "Tad's Death" Tape
- Legend of Zelda: Gateway to Hell
- Let the cursed doll go
- Life's Little Joy
- Lily's Souls Consuming Game
- Link and the face of Link
- Little Big Death
- Little Big Planet
- LloviantsGoodbye.sb2
- LoadingSkills' Roblox Creepypasta
- Looney Tunes Lost Episode
- Lorax.avi
- Lost BFDI Episode
- Lost Sonic Proto
- Lost THX tex trailer: Tex and Ueno
- Lucky Star : Moe Death
- Lucky Star DVD
- Luigi revenge
- LUIGI.exe
- Luigi: The Watcher
M
- M.I.L.K.
- Malcolm in the Middle Lost Episode
- Manor of Secrets
- MapleStory: Undesired Consequences
- Mario Kart 8
- Mario's Pasta House
- Mariodeath666.win
- Markus's Past - Why Minecraft was Created
- Meme Theory
- Messed up umbreon
- Metroid Creepypasta
- Michael Rodent
- Mickey Mouse Clubhouse: Banned Episode
- Mickey Mouse's Nightmare
- Mickey mouse: true love
- Mindcraft
- Minecraft - Endiousity the Daylight Enderman
- Minecraft - Mirror Mirror
- Minecraft eerie seed
- Minecraft: Version from Hell
- Missingno's Curse
- Mister Rodger's Neighborhood Lost Episode
- MLP Season 5 - Episode 14 - True Friendship
- Mokey's Show: Darkness
- Moleka, Not the Normal Robloxian
- Monster High lost episode
- Monsters, Aliens, and Humans
- Mr Funny Guy
- Mr. Krab's Bankruptcy 2 - Safe Deposit Squidward
- Mr. Krabs Insanity
- Mushroom Wojak (Shroomjack)
- Music of Lavender Town
- My Creepy File
- My Fair Lad-E
- My friend died in a car accident while watching Thomas and friends
- My Haunted Keyboard
- My Little Pony: Friendship Is Magic - The Lost Episode
- My little sister murdered my entire family and it's all my fault
- My Pen
- My Teacher from Hell
- Mystery Men (Part One)
N
O
P
- Pac-Man Creepypasta - Pac-Choke
- Pac-Man Theory
- Patrick the Killer
- PBS Freakout
- PBS Parody Missing Video
- PBS: Lost Logo
- Peppa Pig - Lost Episode: Why?
- Peppa Pig Lost Episode: Richard Rabbit's Death
- Peppa Pig Real Face
- Peppa Pig: Daddy Pig's Revenge
- Peppa's Juice
- Peri.avi
- Persona3: The Haunting
- Phineas.exe
- Pingu (2022) Deleted Scenes
- Pingu's New Generation
- PL4NT5 V5 Z0MB135
- Play or Die
- PLAZMA BURST 2 CREEPY GAEM
- Pocoyo Lost Episode
- Pokemon BloodMoon
- Pokemon Red...
- Pokémon Twilight Wings: Episode 666
- Polly Susan
- Porky's Killer Adventure
- Project Nekomata
- PS2 Red Edition
- Psycho Foxx
- Puppy Dog Pals: The Last Mission
- Purple Chao
R
- R6s hidden map
- Rainbow.exe: The Creepypasta Story
- Rant on Fedora Haters
- Rarity's Bathroom
- Real Scary Guy Meme
- Reanimated By Disney: A Sequal To Abandoned By Disney
- Red Lightning
- Redvsblue.avi
- Regular Show: Rigby's Suicide
- Ren and Stimpy: Found Footage Lost Episode
- Revival of Moral Orel
- Rex the Killer
- Rick and Morty Lost Episode Entry's
- Roblox "User?" Disjointless
- Roblox 666
- ROBLOX And Friends Lost Episode - No Ways Out
- Roblox April Fools
- Roblox Dream
- Roblox Nemoy's Dusk
- Roblox: Builderman
- ROBOTS.AVI
- Rocko's Modern Life: Lost Episode
- RonaldvsBK2.mp4
- Room 536
- ROSE SLEEPYEYES
- Rugrats: Tommy Dies
- Running Man
S
- Sammy
- Sandy's Bad Hair Day
- Scott the Woz: E.T
- Sesame Street Series Finale
- Sesame Street: The Fan Made Episode
- Shadow's Mask
- SHINE!
- Shrek The Deleted Scene
- Shrek.swf
- Shrek: Deleted Scene
- Skyrim Nightmare
- Skyrim Nightmare 2
- Slenderfic
- Smiley RPG
- Smiling Friends Lost Episode: EVERYTHING HURTS
- Smokey's Night of Indefinite Flames
- Sneaky Agent
- Some Mates
- Sonic 2006 CreepyPasta
- Sonic 2006 CreepyPasta - The AfterMath
- Sonic 2: The Lost Beta
- Sonic Adventure 2: You've Done This: Final Chapter (Rewrite and further fleshed out)
- Sonic Alone
- Sonic Suicide
- Sonic.exe - Rewrite by Saum22
- Sonic.exe: The Boy of Dreams
- Sonic.jpg
- Soul Creek
- Space Invaders : The Haunted Cabinet
- Special Ed
- Speed Punks: The Lost Punk
- Spengbab
- Spider Man's Death
- Spider-Man 1 Scrapped Cut
- Spider-Man: Extended Edition
- Sponge Weird
- Spongeb0b
- Spongebob - Bankrupt
- SpongeBob - Help Wanted (alternative ending)
- Spongebob Drug Theory
- Spongebob Ends the World
- SpongeBob Lost Episode: Cold
- Spongebob Lost Episode: Patrick's Sacrifice
- Spongebob Season 1 Full DVD 2002
- SpongeBob SquarePants - Lost Episode: Patrick's Death
- SpongeBob SquarePants Lost 2005 Episode
- Spongebob Squarepants Lost DVD: Squidward The Killer
- Spongebob Squarepants The Lost Episode: "Death at Christmas"
- Spongebob Squarepants: "WHY"
- SpongeBob SquarePants: Bob.avi
- SpongeBob SquarePants: Rock Bottom (Original Version)
- SpongeBob SquarePants: the Lost Episode: Haunted DVD
- Spongebob Squarepants: The Suffering
- Spongebob Squarepants: Worth Dying For
- Spongebob The Ugly Barnacle Comes to Bikini Bottom
- SpongeBob Unreleased Special Episode
- SpongeBob's Revenge
- Spongebob's Schizophrenia
- SpongeBob: Patrick the Killer Eater
- SPONGEBOBCRYING.AVI
- Spongebobmadness.avi
- Squidward kills spongbob
- Squidward's Rampage
- Squidward's Secret
- Squidward's Suicide - The Production
- Stay fresh
- Steven Universe: Connie's Depression
- Stewie's Sinister Secret
- Stewy.exe
- Stick Man
- Still Here... Waiting
- Stories of a cow rancher
- Stories of a cow rancher 2: Mystery Car
- Strange Noises
- Suckers Lost Episode
- Super Mario 64 - Fate of Death
- Super Mario 64 Haunted Cartridge
- Super Mario Bros Movie - Dog Attack (Alternate Version)
- Super Mario Bros. Creepypasta
- Super Mario Logan: The Nuclear Explosion
- Super Mario Murders
- Super Mario Party (SNES)
- Super Mario Party 2006
- Super Mario Red
- Super Mario World: Yoshi-Dies.avi
- Super Mario's Castle Fun
- SuperMario64.exe
T
- Tails Doll: My Experience
- TAWOG Goodbye Forever Gumball
- TAWOG Unaired Episode
- Taxi Kermit
- Tboi. Exe
- TDU2: Champion Files
- Team Fortress 2 The Weird Server
- Team Fortress Boo
- Teletubbies lost episode. Boats
- Teletubbies: Lost Episode
- Terror-Bytes
- The Adventures of Sonic the Hedgehog: Sonic Dies
- The Advertisement
- The Alamo
- The Amazing World Of Gumball: The Bunny II
- The Bad Side of Cartoons
- The Big Badge App: Secret Ending
- The Big Comfy Couch lost episode
- The blue demon
- The Bootleg Baby Hazel Game
- The borealis
- The Chainsaw Option
- The Creepy Angry Bird
- The Creepy Building
- The Cube Theory
- The Dark Knight Rises: First Draft
- The Dark Mist
- The Deleted Scene
- The Demon Within
- The Doctor and Jeff the killer
- The Dog is Doing Nothing
- The Enigma of the Eternity Cube
- The Evil Creeper Trilogy
- The Exodus of Krähendorf Felsen
- The Face
- The Flintstones Series Finale
- The Flower Fan of Doom
- The Formidables