Category:Not Sure if Troll or Trying to Be Serious
Creepypastas so horrible, that you can't even tell if they're creepypastas or not. You also think of it as a fanfiction rather than a creepypasta.
Pages in category "Not Sure if Troll or Trying to Be Serious"
The following 500 pages are in this category, out of 606 total.
(previous page) (next page)0
5
9
A
- A Cursed Nostalgia
- A Demon With A Lisp
- A Kitten's Story: The Adventures of Chatran
- A Love Letter to Creepypasta
- A New Generation: Director's Cut
- A Night of Nick GaS
- A Really Hidden Powerpuff Tape
- A Visit from Jeff
- A weird phone call......(scary but not that scary)
- Abandoned by SEGA
- Acid Does Plague
- Adventure Time: Lost Episode
- Adventures of the Little Koala Lost Episode
- Aggretsuko: Retsuko Says Goodbye
- Alexa's Grieving
- Alexa.bat
- All Gone (awful original version)
- Alligators in the House
- AlphNation - Bye-Bye, Dark
- Always Watch What Part of Latin America You're Going To
- Always Watching
- Amazing World of Gumball: The Pizza: Alternate Ending
- Amiibos Have Feelings....
- Among us (lost early version)
- Angry birds: dust and ash
- Animaniacs Hulu 2020 Reboot: The Fire
- Animaul Crossings: New Blood
- Annie Christmas
- Another Plants vs. Zombies Creepypasta
- Any massacre at midnight
- Apartment 366
- Apartment 3H
- Arcade Nightmare
- Arnold the Octopus
- Around The World In 80 Days Lost episode
- Ashberry
B
- Back to The Future Never Happened Theory
- Bad Bowser
- Bad Choices
- Ball Guy: The Rolling Quest (FINAL BUILD/2024 BUILD)
- Banjo Tooie: The Darkness Rises
- Bart And The Murder Mutants
- Battle For Death Island: Revenge
- Beavis and Butthead - "Fire, Fire, Fire!"
- Beavis and Butthead in: Solitude
- Beetlejuice, Beetlejuice, Beetlejuice
- Better Luck Next Time
- BFB 911: Unknown Kills
- BFDI: TPOT 1 (EARLY DRAFT)
- Billy and Bobby Rare 1988 NES Game
- Blaze.exe
- Blimps in Baltimore
- Blood On My Walls
- Blue's Clues: Help Blue
- Blue's Clues: Where's Blue?
- Blues Clues: Disability Aid for Impaired Humans
- Bluey - Daddy Massacre (FANONPASTA)
- Bluey...?
- Bob can't do it
- Bob's Burgers: Crazy Tina
- Brian Jacques' Redwall Theory
- Broken Roof
- Buhdeuce Abuse
- BuzzFeed A.I
- Bynary Message
C
- C0rRUPT
- Caillou: Darkness
- Caillou: Mommy's Secret
- Camp Lazlo Season Six
- CandleCove In Nick?
- Cannibal Jenny (Lost Episode)
- Captain Flamingo - Origins
- CatDog Banned Episode: The End
- Cell Phone
- Cheap Condoms
- Cheek to Cheek With Death
- Chikn Nuggit: The Ten Secret TikToks
- Classic Cartoons and Baby Shows Theory
- Cleveland Bites the Dust
- Could Jesus be the Antichrist
- Counter-Strike: Source
- Cracked Minecraft
- Cranberry Juice
- Crashbox - Lost Episode
- Crazy Cat
- CREEPIEST CLEVERBOT CHAT EVER
- Crossy Road Unreleased Character
- Crystal Pepsi Lost Commercial
- Curious George - Bill's Bad News
- Cursed Shake Creepypasta
- Cursed YTMND Page
- Cyberplace: Cyberchase's Lost Pilot
- Cyrus Syndrome
D
- Damned Grand Theft Auto 4
- Daniel Tiger's Neighborhood: Cakes (Alternate Episode)
- Daniel Tiger's Neighborhood: Daniel's Last Rites
- Dead Mann
- Dead Mat
- DEADCRY.gif
- Deadpool Slaughterific
- Death By Sega
- Death drugs
- Demo Reel 2: The Backlash
- Demo Reel Lost Episode
- Diddykongracing.jpg
- Dig 1990 - The Actual Movie
- Disney Cinderella is Evil
- Do the Bart...Man...
- Donkey Kong Country: Beta Cartridge
- Donkey Kong Country: DK's Rampage
- Dont leave
- Dont watch it
- Doofenhmirtz's kills everyone
- Dorky's Revenge
- Dot Warner Doll
- Dratini's Cry
- Drowned Sapphire
- DukeyAndFriendsDukeysLastGive.mp4
E
F
- Family Burden
- Family Guy Theory
- Family Guy: Peter's Relationship
- Family Guy: Season 8 Episode 0: The Bloody Sunset
- Fatman
- Fay The Killer
- Felix the Cat
- Finding Nemo Video Game: The Secret Backrooms Level
- FNAT
- Focus Punch 560
- For Glory
- For the birds
- Four Doors
- Freddy Freaker
- Freesmart.avi
- Frozen Lost Clip
- Frozen Minecraft
G
- Game Over...
- Game.exe
- Garfield And Friends: Garfield's Hunt
- Garfield.wmv
- Garry's Mod 666
- Gengars Curse
- GoAnimate
- Golden Girls Lost Episode
- Good and bad tails doll
- Goodbye Pikachu
- Goodbye SpongeBoy
- Goodbye, Sonic
- Google Surprise
- Grand Theft Auto: Satandreas
- Grandma Melinda
- Gravity Falls Lost Episode - My very first pasta
- Gravity Falls: The Lost Episode
- Greatest Freakout Ever Lost Episode
H
- Hacker Team
- Halo Reach Crazy Scary Story
- Happy Family
- Happy Tree Friends: The Lost Special
- Harvey Beaks Lost Episode: The Real World
- Have a Scaly Halloween
- He Caused His Own Fate
- Hell Stick
- Hello?
- Herobrine Is Real
- Herobrine Killed Everything
- Hey Duggee - The Grandparents Badge (Alternate Version)
- Hey Duggee: The Pain Badge
- Him
- Homer's Last Laugh
- Homestuck - Rough Draft
- Homicidal Taco
- Hotel Transylvania 3: Summer Vacation Alternate Ending
- Hotel Transylvania The Series: The Bad Prank
- House No. 13
- How My Friend Became a Zombie
- HowToBasic: Lost Video
I
- I dont understand my condition
- I know what is coming for you
- I'll Never Close My Eyes Again
- Ibi.exe
- Ibi.exe (2024 remake)
- Ibi.exe II: Wanna Play With Me?
- Ibi.exe II: Wanna Play With Me? (2024 remake)
- IIM NOT MAD
- Imaginary Friend
- Impractical Jokers Lost Episode
- Inanimate Insanity S0 E0:Box's True Form
- Insane
- Insane serenity
- Invader Zim: Gir's Rage
J
K
L
- Lavender The Hedgehog .exe
- Lazari
- LazyTown - A Coffin For Stingy
- LazyTown Episode 4355
- LazyTown: The Anime Series
- Leap Frog: The "Tad's Death" Tape
- Legend of Zelda: Gateway to Hell
- Let the cursed doll go
- Life's Little Joy
- Lily's Souls Consuming Game
- Link and the face of Link
- Little Big Death
- Little Big Planet
- LloviantsGoodbye.sb2
- LoadingSkills' Roblox Creepypasta
- Looney Tunes Lost Episode
- Lorax.avi
- Lost BFDI Episode
- Lost Sonic Proto
- Lost THX tex trailer: Tex and Ueno
- Lucky Star : Moe Death
- Lucky Star DVD
- Luigi revenge
- LUIGI.exe
- Luigi: The Watcher
M
- M.I.L.K.
- Malcolm in the Middle Lost Episode
- Manor of Secrets
- MapleStory: Undesired Consequences
- Mario Kart 8
- Mario's Pasta House
- Mariodeath666.win
- Markus's Past - Why Minecraft was Created
- Meme Theory
- Messed up umbreon
- Metroid Creepypasta
- Michael Rodent
- Mickey Mouse Clubhouse: Banned Episode
- Mickey Mouse's Nightmare
- Mickey mouse: true love
- Mindcraft
- Minecraft - Endiousity the Daylight Enderman
- Minecraft - Mirror Mirror
- Minecraft eerie seed
- Minecraft: Version from Hell
- Missingno's Curse
- Mister Rodger's Neighborhood Lost Episode
- MLP Season 5 - Episode 14 - True Friendship
- Mokey's Show: Darkness
- Moleka, Not the Normal Robloxian
- Monster High lost episode
- Monsters, Aliens, and Humans
- Mr Funny Guy
- Mr. Krab's Bankruptcy 2 - Safe Deposit Squidward
- Mr. Krabs Insanity
- Mushroom Wojak (Shroomjack)
- Music of Lavender Town
- My Creepy File
- My Fair Lad-E
- My friend died in a car accident while watching Thomas and friends
- My Haunted Keyboard
- My Little Pony: Friendship Is Magic - The Lost Episode
- My little sister murdered my entire family and it's all my fault
- My Pen
- My Teacher from Hell
- Mystery Men (Part One)
N
O
P
- Pac-Man Creepypasta - Pac-Choke
- Pac-Man Theory
- Patrick the Killer
- PBS Freakout
- PBS Parody Missing Video
- PBS: Lost Logo
- Peppa Pig - Lost Episode: Why?
- Peppa Pig Lost Episode: Richard Rabbit's Death
- Peppa Pig Real Face
- Peppa Pig: Daddy Pig's Revenge
- Peppa's Juice
- Peri.avi
- Persona3: The Haunting
- Phineas.exe
- Pingu (2022) Deleted Scenes
- Pingu's New Generation
- PL4NT5 V5 Z0MB135
- Play or Die
- PLAZMA BURST 2 CREEPY GAEM
- Pocoyo Lost Episode
- Pokemon BloodMoon
- Pokemon Red...
- Pokémon Twilight Wings: Episode 666
- Polly Susan
- Porky's Killer Adventure
- Project Nekomata
- PS2 Red Edition
- Psycho Foxx
- Puppy Dog Pals: The Last Mission
- Purple Chao
R
- R6s hidden map
- Rainbow.exe: The Creepypasta Story
- Rant on Fedora Haters
- Rarity's Bathroom
- Real Scary Guy Meme
- Reanimated By Disney: A Sequal To Abandoned By Disney
- Red Lightning
- Redvsblue.avi
- Regular Show: Rigby's Suicide
- Ren and Stimpy: Found Footage Lost Episode
- Revival of Moral Orel
- Rex the Killer
- Rick and Morty Lost Episode Entry's
- Roblox "User?" Disjointless
- Roblox 666
- ROBLOX And Friends Lost Episode - No Ways Out
- Roblox April Fools
- Roblox Dream
- Roblox Nemoy's Dusk
- Roblox: Builderman
- ROBOTS.AVI
- Rocko's Modern Life: Lost Episode
- RonaldvsBK2.mp4
- Room 536
- ROSE SLEEPYEYES
- Rugrats: Tommy Dies
- Running Man
S
- Sammy
- Sandy's Bad Hair Day
- Scott the Woz: E.T
- Sesame Street Series Finale
- Sesame Street: The Fan Made Episode
- Shadow's Mask
- SHINE!
- Shrek The Deleted Scene
- Shrek.swf
- Shrek: Deleted Scene
- Skyrim Nightmare
- Skyrim Nightmare 2
- Slenderfic
- Smiley RPG
- Smiling Friends Lost Episode: EVERYTHING HURTS
- Smokey's Night of Indefinite Flames
- Sneaky Agent
- Some Mates
- Sonic 2006 CreepyPasta
- Sonic 2006 CreepyPasta - The AfterMath
- Sonic 2: The Lost Beta
- Sonic Adventure 2: You've Done This: Final Chapter (Rewrite and further fleshed out)
- Sonic Alone
- Sonic Suicide
- Sonic.exe - Rewrite by Saum22
- Sonic.exe: The Boy of Dreams
- Sonic.jpg
- Soul Creek
- Space Invaders : The Haunted Cabinet
- Special Ed
- Speed Punks: The Lost Punk
- Spengbab
- Spider Man's Death
- Spider-Man 1 Scrapped Cut
- Spider-Man: Extended Edition
- Sponge Weird
- Spongeb0b
- Spongebob - Bankrupt
- SpongeBob - Help Wanted (alternative ending)
- Spongebob Drug Theory
- Spongebob Ends the World
- SpongeBob Lost Episode: Cold
- Spongebob Lost Episode: Patrick's Sacrifice
- Spongebob Season 1 Full DVD 2002
- SpongeBob SquarePants - Lost Episode: Patrick's Death
- SpongeBob SquarePants Lost 2005 Episode
- Spongebob Squarepants Lost DVD: Squidward The Killer
- Spongebob Squarepants The Lost Episode: "Death at Christmas"
- Spongebob Squarepants: "WHY"
- SpongeBob SquarePants: Bob.avi
- SpongeBob SquarePants: Rock Bottom (Original Version)
- SpongeBob SquarePants: the Lost Episode: Haunted DVD
- Spongebob Squarepants: The Suffering
- Spongebob Squarepants: Worth Dying For
- Spongebob The Ugly Barnacle Comes to Bikini Bottom
- SpongeBob Unreleased Special Episode
- SpongeBob's Revenge
- Spongebob's Schizophrenia
- SpongeBob: Patrick the Killer Eater
- SPONGEBOBCRYING.AVI
- Spongebobmadness.avi
- Squidward kills spongbob
- Squidward's Rampage
- Squidward's Secret
- Squidward's Suicide - The Production
- Stay fresh
- Steven Universe: Connie's Depression
- Stewie's Sinister Secret
- Stewy.exe
- Stick Man
- Still Here... Waiting
- Stories of a cow rancher
- Stories of a cow rancher 2: Mystery Car
- Strange Noises
- Suckers Lost Episode
- Super Mario 64 - Fate of Death
- Super Mario 64 Haunted Cartridge
- Super Mario Bros Movie - Dog Attack (Alternate Version)
- Super Mario Bros. Creepypasta
- Super Mario Logan: The Nuclear Explosion
- Super Mario Murders
- Super Mario Party (SNES)
- Super Mario Party 2006
- Super Mario Red
- Super Mario World: Yoshi-Dies.avi
- Super Mario's Castle Fun
- SuperMario64.exe
T
- Tails Doll: My Experience
- TAWOG Goodbye Forever Gumball
- TAWOG Unaired Episode
- Taxi Kermit
- Tboi. Exe
- TDU2: Champion Files
- Team Fortress 2 The Weird Server
- Team Fortress Boo
- Teletubbies lost episode. Boats
- Teletubbies: Lost Episode
- Terror-Bytes
- The Adventures of Sonic the Hedgehog: Sonic Dies
- The Advertisement
- The Alamo
- The Amazing World Of Gumball: The Bunny II
- The Bad Side of Cartoons
- The Big Badge App: Secret Ending
- The Big Comfy Couch lost episode
- The blue demon
- The Bootleg Baby Hazel Game
- The borealis
- The Chainsaw Option
- The Creepy Angry Bird
- The Creepy Building
- The Cube Theory
- The Dark Knight Rises: First Draft
- The Dark Mist
- The Deleted Scene
- The Demon Within
- The Doctor and Jeff the killer
- The Dog is Doing Nothing
- The Enigma of the Eternity Cube
- The Evil Creeper Trilogy
- The Exodus of Krähendorf Felsen
- The Face
- The Flintstones Series Finale
- The Flower Fan of Doom
- The Formidables